Straight-talking HR for the people doing payroll, sales and playing workplace therapist before lunch.
If you run a UK small business, or you're the HR-of-one trying to keep the wheels on, this podcast is for you.
No corporate jargon.
No "synergy."
Just real answers to the people's problems no one warned you about.
Hosted by award-winning HR expert Kate Underwood, each episode tackles the moments small business owners actually face:
The employee who's brilliant at the job and causes chaos in the team
The manager who avoids hard conversations until they turn into a bonfire
The "small issue" grievance that suddenly becomes a formal complaint
The sickness pattern is suspiciously linked to Mondays and payday
The resignation that makes you think, " What did we miss?"
You'll get plain-English UK employment law, practical advice on performance, absence, hiring and retention, and grown-up culture conversations, all usable the same day. No theory. No paperwork museums. No advice that only works in big HR departments with unlimited budgets.
This is also a permission slip to lead like a human. Clear standards. Fair boundaries. Decent communication. Less drama. The goal is a calmer workplace, fewer sleepless nights, and a team that actually wants to stick around.
And yes, Hazel the office dog pops up too. Because nothing says "people management" quite like a judgmental stare from a Wellbeing Officer who's never written a policy in her life.
☕ Start here: take the FREE HR Health Check and see where your risks and your quick wins are hiding.
Payroll Mistakes That Make People Leave (And How to Fix Them Fast)
•Kate Underwood•Season 1•Episode 35
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
0:00
|
18:16
If you’ve ever said “we’ll fix payroll next month”… this one’s for you.
Because payroll isn’t admin. Payroll is trust.
And once that trust wobbles, people don’t shout about it. They quietly update their CV.
In this episode of Buzzing About HR, Kate breaks down the payroll mistakes that make good people leave and how to fix them quickly, properly, and without drama.
We start with the reality. Most payroll issues in small businesses aren’t deliberate. They’re process problems. Late inputs, missing overtime, confusing holiday pay, or everyone assuming someone else has checked.
But when pay is wrong, the impact is bigger than the amount. It creates doubt.
Do they value me?
Is this going to keep happening?
Can I rely on this business?
From there, we walk through the most common payroll mistakes that damage trust:
Late payroll runs that create stress and panic
Missing overtime or commission because it lives in messages or memory
Holiday pay confusion that no one explains properly
Deductions that feel unclear or unfair
And the classic “we’ll correct it next month” that quietly breaks confidence
Then we get practical.
You’ll get a simple payroll system you can actually use. A clear timetable with deadlines. One source of truth for variable pay. A 10-minute pre-check that catches errors before they land. And a fast, human response process for when mistakes do happen.
Because mistakes will happen. What matters is how quickly and clearly you fix them.
We also cover manager accountability, why payroll always needs an owner, and how small tweaks like cut-off rules and one place for queries can reduce errors overnight.
The thread running through all of this is simple.
Clear process.
Consistent checks.
Fast fixes.
That’s what keeps payroll boring. And boring payroll is exactly what your team needs.
If payroll has started to feel like a monthly headache, or you’ve had a few near misses recently, this episode will help you steady it.
Press play and take back control before your best people start quietly looking elsewhere.
If you’re not 100% sure how your HR is really holding up, take our free HR Health Check. It’s short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what’s working — and what needs a bit of love.
And if you do it before 30th October 2026 you’ll get a bonus 7 Pillar Strategy-on-a-Page, tailored to help you manage HR brilliantly for the year ahead.
That’s it for today, but if you fancy a bit of friendly HR advice in your inbox (with zero waffle), come and join our newsletter.
We send out bite-sized tips, plain-English updates, and handy things you’ll actually use — no spam, no fluff.
If you're not sure how your HR is really holding up, take the free HR Health Check. It's short, jargon-free, and gives you a clear score on what's working and what could do with a bit of love.
Enjoyed this episode? Subscribe so you never miss one, and leave a review if you've got thirty seconds. It honestly does help more small business owners find the show, and it's the cheapest good deed you'll do all week.
You know what's wild? People will forgive a lot in a small business. They'll forgive the odd all hands on deck week. They'll forgive the printer that only works when you threaten it. They'll forgive the fact the kettle has clearly joined a union and is refusing to boil. But get their pay wrong? Twice? That's when they update their CV in silence, and you only find out when they hand their notice in with a polite smile and the emotional warmth of a fridge. Hazel is here by the way. She's our chief payroll auditor. Not because she can do maths, because she can sense stress from two rooms away. And she appears the second anyone says the words overtime or pay slip, like it's a cheese-related emergency. This is Buzzing About HR, and today we're talking payroll mistakes that make people leave. And how to fix them fast, properly, without drama. And yes, I know payroll can feel like boring admin. But payroll isn't admin. Payroll is trust. Break it, and you'll spend months trying to rebuild it. Hello and welcome back. It's Kate. This episode is for business owners, managers, anyone who approves timesheets, and anyone who's ever said, just run
payroll and we'll fix it next month. Because fix it next month is how you accidentally create a team of people who don't trust you. And the timing of this is perfect because National Payroll Week runs 1 to 5 September, and the fallout always lands straight after. Wrong pay. Missing overtime, holiday pay confusion, late payroll runs, people checking their bank accounts like it's a crime scene. So today I'm going to give you a very practical, very doable process you can put in place immediately, even if you've got no HR team and payroll sits with whoever is least busy. The Hive Brief. Let's get real about why payroll mistakes hit so hard. Payroll is the one part of employment that is meant to be non-negotiable. Your staff give you their time, effort, energy, and in return they expect to be paid correctly and on time. When payroll goes wrong, it doesn't just create inconvenience, it creates doubt. People start thinking, do they value me? Is the business stable? Is this going to keep happening? Do they even notice how hard I
work? And that's why payroll errors make people leave. Not because of the amount. Because of the message it sends. Now, most payroll mistakes in small businesses aren't malicious. They're process mistakes. Missing information, late approvals, confusing rules, manual calculations, or everyone assuming someone else has checked. So we're going to tackle it. Like a system, not a blame game. The sting. Right, we're going to do two things. First, the biggest payroll mistakes that destroy trust. Second, the practical fix. Including the exact checklists, deadlines and scripts you need. Mistake one, late payroll. This is the nuclear one. Late pay doesn't just annoy people, it scares them. Bills bounce, direct debits fail, rent is due, people feel embarrassed, and they don't forget it. Practical fix. Set a payroll
timetable and make it non-negotiable. Here's what you need. Timesheet deadline. Overtime deadline. Payroll input deadline. Payroll sign-off deadline. Payday. Then put it in a shared calendar. And this is key. Build-in buffer. Don't set your deadline the day before payday. Give yourself breathing space for errors. If payday is Friday, your cutoff needs to be Monday or Tuesday, not Thursday at 4 pm while you're also chasing a supplier. Hazel just lifted her head at the word cut off because she thinks it means the cheese is being cut. It isn't Hazel. Not yet. Mistake 2. Missing overtime, commission, or enhancements. This happens when overtime lives in a WhatsApp message, a scribble on paper, or someone's memory. Practical fix. One source of truth for variable pay. You need one log. Spreadsheet is fine. Columns you need, employee name, date, hours or units. Reason. Overtime, call out, commission, shift enhancement. Approved by payroll month. And you make one rule. No log, no pay. Not to be mean. To make it fair and consistent. Mistake three. Holiday pay confusion. This one causes endless frustration because people don't understand what they're being paid and why it changes. Practical fix. Two parts. Part one. Make holiday booking and recording bulletproof. Part two. Explain holiday pay on one page in plain English. For the booking and recording bit. One holiday tracker. Holidays are not booked until approved. And the payroll person checks holiday taken against the tracker every pay run. For the explain it bit, tell people how holiday pay is calculated in your business, especially if they do overtime or variable hours. Even a short message helps. Your holiday pay is based on your normal pay. If you regularly do overtime, that may affect holiday pay calculations. If you have a question, ask before payday and we'll check it. Mistake 4. Wrong deductions. People take deductions personally. It feels like you've taken money off them unfairly. Practical fix. Any non-statutory deduction must be confirmed in writing. What it is. Why it's being deducted. How much? Over how long? And who they can speak to if they query it. Mistake 5. We'll correct it next month. This is the trust killer. If payroll is wrong and you say we'll fix it next month, what employees hear is your money isn't urgent. Practical fix. A fast correction process and a promise. If someone is underpaid, you correct it as quickly as possible. If you can run an off-cycle payment, do it. If you can't, give the exact date it will land. And you put that in writing. Mistake six. Payroll has no owner. In small businesses, payroll often belongs to whoever is least busy, which is nobody. Practical fix. Assign roles, payroll owner, payroll checker, payroll approver. Even if two roles are done by one person, the responsibility must be clear. If payroll is outsourced, the owner still exists internally. The provider doesn't know your overtime rules, your holiday patterns, or who joined last week. You do. Mistake 7. Managers submit info late. This is the hidden cause of most pay issues. Practical fix. Manager accountability with a simple rule. If it's not submitted by cutoff, it goes in next month unless the business error caused the delay. Otherwise, managers can wreck payroll and the payroll person gets blamed. Now, here's the spicy what if. What if your best employee doesn't leave because of workload? But because you got their pay wrong twice? They might not even tell you that's why. They'll just quietly decide they're done. So let's talk about exactly how to handle a payroll mistake when it happens. Because mistakes will happen. What matters is your response. Here's the payroll mistake response process. Step one, acknowledge same day. No defensiveness. No blame. No, are you sure? Script. Thanks for flagging this. I'm checking it today and I'll come back to you by 3 pm. Step two. Confirm the issue in one sentence. Over time missing. Wrong hours. Wrong holiday pay, wrong deduction. Step three.
Confirm the fix and the date. Script. You're owed X pounds. We will pay it by X date. You'll see it as description on your pay slip. Step four. Apologize like a human. Not a corporate apology. A normal one. I'm sorry. This shouldn't have happened. I've corrected it. And I'm fixing the process so it doesn't repeat. Step five. Fix the root cause. Because if it happens again, you lose trust. Now, prevention. This is where you win. You need a payroll pre-check process. It should take 10 to 15 minutes, not an afternoon. Here is the pre-check list. New starters added correctly. Levers removed and final pay correct. Salary changes confirmed in writing. Overtime log approved and entered. Holiday. Taken recorded and entered. Deductions checked and authorized. Random spot check on two pay slips. Payroll sign off completed. And I want you to add one more check that
most SMEs forget. Check the outliers. Who has a big change this month? A lot more overtime, a lot less pay, a large deduction, a new starter, a contract change. Outliers are where mistakes hide. Hazel loves an outlier. Mainly because it sounds like treat time. But still, good instincts. Now, let's talk about the two practical things that reduce payroll mistakes overnight. Number one, cutoff communication. Every month the payroll owner sends a message to managers. Payroll cutoff is Tuesday at 12 pm. Overtime logs and timesheets must be approved by then. Anything late goes into next month unless it's a business error. Number two, a single place for payroll questions. If your staff don't know who to ask, they ask their mate, their manager, or they stew in silence. So tell them. If you have a payroll query, email, address, or speak to name. We'll respond within 24 hours. Now, if you've had multiple mistakes and the team is edgy, you need to rebuild payroll trust. Here's the simple trust repair process. One, acknowledge it. We know there have been payroll errors recently. We're sorry and we're fixing the process. Two, put the process in place. Timetable, log, checks. Three. Tell staff what will happen if there's an error. Same day acknowledgement fixed by X written confirmation.
Four. Deliver consistently for three pay cycles. That's when trust starts to return. Legal angel, and here's the bit I want you to clock. Pay and holiday pay issues are some of the most common things that end up escalating into formal disputes. If people aren't paid correctly or holiday pay is wrong, they can end up going down the tribunal route and tribunals can award money owed, including unpaid wages and unpaid holiday pay. So don't treat payroll errors like a minor admin hiccup. They're one of the fastest ways to trigger complaints, grievances, and I'm done energy. And yes, you can live in
hope that nobody will take it further. But hope is not a payroll process. Small business actions. Here's your action plan for this week. One, create a payroll calendar with deadlines for the next three months. Two, build one variable payload with clear approval. Three. Assign a payroll owner and a payroll checker. Create your 10-minute pre-checklist and use it every time. 5. Write your payroll error promise and share it with the team. Here's a simple payroll error. Promise you can copy.
If you spot a payroll error, tell us straight away. We'll acknowledge it the same day, confirm the issue by 3 pm, and correct it as quickly as possible. We'll always tell you what's happening and when you'll be paid. This week's challenge. Pick one thing today. Either create your payroll cutoff calendar for the next three months. Or build your variable paylog and agree who approves it. Or write the payroll error promise and send it to your team. Small action. Massive trust boost. Payroll isn't admin. Payroll is trust. You can have the best culture in the world, but if people don't trust their pay, they won't trust you. So keep it boring, keep it consistent, and if a mistake happens, fix it fast and fix it properly. And if you're listening thinking, Kate, we're a small business and payroll is a constant headache. I hear you. This is something we can help with. We can support you to tighten up the process, train managers on what they need to submit and when, put the right checks in place, and help you stop payroll mistakes landing on your desk every month like an unwanted subscription. Hazel oversees payroll too. Mainly by sitting beside me while I'm checking figures and giving a judgmental sigh whenever she senses stress. Honestly, it's very effective.
One last thing before you go. Employment tribunals and early conciliation don't fill up because businesses are evil. They fill up because small things get left too long, and pay and holiday pay disputes are classic examples. Get it wrong, don't fix it quickly, and you're basically volunteering to become someone else's case study. Don't become a statistic. If payroll and holidays are a recurring headache in your business, we can help you tighten the process, build the checks, and get it boring and consistent again. So your team trusts you and you stop dreading payday. If you want to book a call and do a quick payroll health check, you know where to find me. Kettle on, standards up. See you next time.
